| Name | Dates |
|---|---|
| Unknown | 1816 |
| Ignatius Algonquin | 1809-1813 |
| Annance | 1816 |
| Archelaus Annance | 1841-1844 |
| Cartnache Annance | 1830(?) |
| Francis Joseph Annance | 1775 |
| James Joseph Annance | 1831 |
| Louis Annance | 1803-1809 |
| Noel Annance | 1808-1813 |
| Peter Annance | 1826-1831 |
| Simon Annance | 1815-(?)1816 |
| Levi Benedict | 1835-1847 |
| John Bolden | 1778 |
| Anthony Gill | 1775 |
| Benedict Gill | 1775 |
| Francois Gill | 1775 |
| Montuit Gill | 1775 |
| Paul Joseph Gill | 1803-1810 |
| Stanislaus Joseph Gill | 1804-1807 |
| William Gill or William Francis | 1806-1808 |
| Peter Indian | 1772 |
| John Batiste | 1779 |
| Louis Langford | 1810 |
| John Lawless | 1854-1856 |
| John Batiste Masta | 1839-1845 1847-1850 |
| Joseph Alex Masta | 1827-1830 |
| Peter Masta or Peter Osunkherhine |
1822-1823 1826-1829 |
| John Stanislaus | 1832-1835 |
| John Stanislaus, Jr. | 1832-1847 |
| Elijah Solon | 1843-(?) |
| Samuel Squintup (Squintap, Squntup, Squontup) |
1771 |
| Elijah Tahamont | 1843-1848 |
| John Taubausanda | 1803-1804 |
| Joseph Taukwermant or Taukerman | 1803-1805 |
| Vincent | 1807 |
| Lewis Vincent |
1772 |
| Sebastian Vincent | 1772 |
| Rev. Eleazar Williams | 1807 |
| Joseph Williams | 1828-1830 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |